This ACH return code applies specifically to RCK (Represented Check Entry) transactions when both the original paper check and the electronic re-presentment of that same check have been presented for payment simultaneously. R53 occurs when there's a duplicate payment attempt using both physical and electronic methods for the same transaction, creating a potential double-payment scenario that the banking system prevents.
Error message: "In addition to an RCK entry, the item to which the RCK entry relates has also been presented for payment."
What Causes ACH Return Code R53?
The R53 ACH return code means "Item and RCK Entry Presented for Payment" and indicates that both the original paper check and its electronic re-presentment through a Represented Check Entry (RCK) have been submitted for payment processing. This creates a dangerous double-payment scenario where the same transaction could potentially be processed twice, causing the customer to be charged double the intended amount.
This situation typically occurs when there's miscommunication or poor coordination between payment processing systems and physical check handling. For example, a merchant might electronically re-present a bounced check through RCK while simultaneously or separately depositing the original physical check again. The banking system detects this duplication and returns the transaction to prevent the customer from being charged twice for the same payment, protecting both the customer and the financial institutions involved.
Can You Retry R53 Payments?
You cannot retry R53 payments using the same methods since both the physical and electronic versions have already been presented. You must choose only one method - either process the original check physically OR use RCK for electronic re-presentment, but never both simultaneously. Contact the customer to clarify the payment situation and choose the most appropriate single payment method going forward.
How to Respond to an R53 Code
An R53 return requires immediate coordination to prevent double-payment confusion and establish clear communication about which payment method will be used going forward.
When Your Customer's Payment Fails
- Contact Customer Immediately
Explain that both the physical check and electronic re-presentment were processed to prevent double-payment confusion. - Clarify Payment Preference
Determine whether the customer prefers the original check to be processed physically or electronically through RCK. - Choose Single Payment Method
Select either physical check processing OR electronic RCK re-presentment, but never both for the same transaction. - Prevent Future Duplications
Implement controls to ensure only one payment method is used per transaction to avoid R53 returns.
Subject: Payment Processing Issue - Double Submission Prevented
Hi [Customer Name],
We attempted to process your payment but received an R53 return code, which means both your original check and our electronic re-presentment were submitted simultaneously. Our banking system prevented this to protect you from being charged twice.
To complete your payment, we need to choose one method:
- Process your original physical check through normal bank channels
- Use electronic re-presentment (RCK) for faster processing
Please let us know which option you prefer, and we'll ensure only that method is used to avoid any duplicate charges or processing confusion.
Thank you for your patience,
[Your Company Name]
When Your Payment to Vendors Fails
An R53 return on vendor payments indicates both the original check and electronic RCK re-presentment were submitted simultaneously. This requires coordination with the vendor to choose a single payment method and prevent duplicate processing.
- Contact the vendor immediately to explain the double-submission situation
- Coordinate to choose either physical check processing OR electronic RCK, not both
- Implement internal controls to prevent simultaneous physical and electronic processing
- Establish clear protocols for handling bounced checks to avoid future R53 returns
Get Unlimited Free ACH Payments
Get unlimited free ACH transfers, smart retries, and real-time payment visibility with Nickel.
Free unlimited ACH transfers
Smart retry scheduling
Real-time payment visibility
Don't just take our word for it
See why thousands of small business owners trust Nickel.
